If the Republicans Invoke the Nuclear Option, It's Double Disaster for the Democrats

President Trump is now urging Senate Republicans to eliminate the filibuster and invoke the so-called "nuclear option" to break the deadlock and reopen the government—an option that's hovered in the background all along.

Under current Senate rules, the filibuster requires 60 votes to advance most legislation. With a 53-47 majority, Republicans can't pass a budget reconciliation bill without Democrat support. And so far, they haven't gotten it. Despite 14 votes by Republicans to reopen the government—with the exception of two GOP holdouts—Democrats have opposed every attempt.

That leaves Democrats in a political bind. Republicans have made it clear. They won't negotiate. Shut down or not, the bill stands as written. Meanwhile, Democrats have muddied the waters with misleading claims about who's responsible for the impasse—a tactic that's backfiring as public frustration mounts.

This standoff isn't just about reopening the government. It's about the rules of engagement going forward. If the Republicans scrap the filibuster and push the bill through with a simple majority, they'll do so without amendments, without compromise, and without Democrat's input. The bill passes "as-is," and the precedent is set.

That's a double loss for Democrats. First, they lose the substance of this negotiation. Second, they lose the structural leverage that allows them to shape future legislation. Without the filibuster, Republicans can pass bills unilaterally until, or unless, the rule is restored.

So, what's the smart play for the Democrats at this juncture? It's to concede this round. Vote to reopen the government. Preserve the filibuster. Live to fight another day.

Because if Democrats force the Republicans to go nuclear, they don't just lose this battle. They lose the battlefield. And while they might try to spin the move as a power grab—"Look what they've done!"—that narrative won't stick. The public is already tuned in, and the longer this drags on, the worse it gets.

Sometimes, the best strategic move is to take one on the chin. This may be that moment.

Like the things I write about or the way I write about them? Follow me on my Facebook page to keep up with the lastest writings wherever I may write them.

©2025 Jim Bauer

Find Jim Bauer other places around the Internet:

Jim Bauer on Spotify (Music)

Jim Bauer on HubPages

Jim Bauer on SoundCloud (Music)